Sanjay
Saxena, expounding on the views of Yuga-rishi Pandit Shriram Sharma Acharya,
quoted that, "Well, if people have completely discarded the genuine
Varna-order (वर्ण-व्यवस्था), and instead
rolled out an unjust and corrupted order, then its utterly unreasonable (अनुचित) to slander the
genuine Varna-order. It's also true that incessant onslaught of attack by
foreign invaders/plunderers and their vicious religious campaigns caused deep socio-religious scars and highly
inequitable distribution of wealth, that created several major defects in the Varna-order.
But, fact remains that no other social system has benefited
the society, so much and for so long, as the varna order did. Even
today, with modest effort, this varna order can again
be fruitfully revived for the upliftment and wellbeing of the society. Due to
prevailing corruption (विकृति), corrosion, degeneration, and
perversion in many aspects of Varna-Order (वर्ण-व्यवस्था), many people
have started seriously accusing it for all the ills of Indian social system
lumping it under a ill-defined and misunderstood foreign label of 'caste'. The
best way to create a resistance against the prevailing corruptions in Varna order is
that, we must revive and re-establish
the genuine-varna-order (सच्ची वर्ण व्यवस्था) starting from it's founding principles.
The truth is that, we are unable to break off the shackles and barriers
of 'jaat-paant' (जात-पांत), because we
have failed to produce new genuine Brahmans, Kshatriyas and Vaishyas that
would be capable of replacing the degenerated ones.
Please continue to read the FULL PAPER below
(down loadable word file and powerpoint presentation attached at the bottom of this page):
**********************************************************************************************************************************
Only Genuine Varna-Order
is Beneficent
(हितकारी सच्ची वर्ण-व्यस्था )
Vedmurti Taponishtha
Yugrishi Pandit Shriram Sharma, Acharya
Founder and Patron
All World Gayatri Pariwar ( www.awgp.org )
and
Sanjay Saxena, PMP
Executive Director, University Advancement
Dev Sanskriti University, Haridwar, Himalayas
Sanjay@DevSanskriti.in
(Based on the interpretive
translation of
"Pandit Shriram Sharma, Acharya Vangmaya"
- Vol.
34, ch.4)
1. Genuine
Varna Order - serves best the
social upliftment
2. Varna
Order in Vedas, Gita, Mahabharat & Manusmriti
3. Gita
and Future Varna Order (गीता और भावी वर्ण व्यस्था)
4. Varna
Order for New Era (नवयुग के अनुरूप वर्ण-व्यवस्था)
5. Towards
Brahmanhood (ब्राह्मणत्व)
Abstract:
Capitalism
and Communism are the two social orders in vogue today. Both are extremely
opposed to each other and have caused disastrous conflicts in the world.
Capitalism strives for concentration of wealth in the hands of a few
capitalists. While as communism strives that no
individual should accumulate wealth. Rather, wealth of the nation should be
equitably distributed. Some serious thinkers have explored India's Varna-Order (वर्ण-व्यस्था), with the
objective of fixing the defects, deficiencies and contradictions between
capitalistic and communistic social orders.
The
Indian Varna-Order strives to allocate work based on individual's qualities,
proficiency, aptitude (योग्यतानुसार) and compensates them as per their situation (स्थिति) and needs (आवश्यकतानुसार). Following three principles can be explicated from
the Varna-Order: (1) Proficiency (कौशल), (2) Interpersonal powerplay (शक्ति-प्रतिमान), (3) Appropriate remuneration (यथायोग्य दक्षिणा).
***************************************************************************************************************************
This
paper proposes to elucidate the principle of genuine Varna-Order. And also
discusses its form and goals.
**************************************************************************************************************************
Varna Order serves best the social upliftment
Many scholars during many time periods, have lucidly
demonstrated the usefulness (उपयोगिता) and virtue (श्रेष्ठता)
of Indian Varna Order (भारतीय वर्ण व्यस्था). With the
help of examples and logic, they have proved that Varna Order is founded on
rational/scientific thought, such that every individual in the society is
afforded the full opportunity for self-development and growth (आत्म
विकास का अवसर). Over ages, Varna
Order helped prevent the social inequality and disharmony of the kind we see
all around in the 20th/21st century. Varna Order propelled Indian society on
the principle of universal brotherhood (विश्व-भ्रातृत्व). All
people were deemed to be part of the same 'Param-Purush' (परम-पुरुष). This
tenet kept in check the discrimination due to people's riches, scholarship,
smarts or stupidity. Thus people lived like a family. Helping others in
distress was deemed to be a natural duty.
But, due to prevailing corruption (विकृति) in many aspects of
Varna-Order, many people have started seriously accusing against it. Some
people go to the extent of claiming that, teachers (ब्राह्मण),
solders (क्षत्रिय),
traders (वैश्य),
and laborers (शूद्र), all
these
do exist in every nation/society, so why make any special publicity (प्रचार)
about varna order. These accusers
neither have grasp of
the principles of Varna (वर्ण)
nor it's order (व्यस्था). It's similar to claiming that,
everybody got hands, legs etc, then what is the need of toning and
strengthening these with nourishing food and regular exercise regime? It's also
like a claim that, throwing the seeds on the earth produces crop, then where is
the need to study agriculture science? But all these people forget that, every
teacher is not a Brahman, every solder is not a Kshatriya, every merchant is
not a Vaishya !
The Real Brahmanhood (ब्रह्मणत्व), Kshatriyahood (क्षत्रियत्व) and Vaishyahood (वैश्यत्व)
In fact, Brahmans are those, who don't merely teach to make a
living, rather they have made it their life's primary goal to spread knowledge.
And, they refuse to quit, no matter how much the temptation of money is
presented to them.
Likewise, every solder is not a Kshatriya, rather, Kshatriyas are those who
have committed their life to remove the injustice from the society and they are
willing to make the ultimate sacrifice while doing so. They will also never
quit, no matter what the circumstances are.
Every tradesman/merchant is not a Vaishya either. Vaishyas are only those
business people, who are committed to produce wealth to remove the poverty and
impoverishment of their society. They will also not quit, even when they
see that Brahmans and Kshatriyas do receive higher honor.
Such, teachers, solders and merchants, don't just automatically
emerge in the society ! For achieving these virtues of true Brahmanhood (ब्रह्मणत्व),
Kshatriyahood (क्षत्रियत्व) and Vaishyahood (वैश्यत्व),
one needs to commit early on in life and work hard in preparation for many-many
years. Then, only one is to ready fulfill the duties demanded by these
Varna-Dharma.
So, that unfolds the mystery of Varna.
Now, let's know about order of 'vyastha' (व्यस्था). A great
society needs that, the job of spreading Truth and knowledge (सत्य और
ज्ञान), should command the highest honor. Although, Khsatriya and
Vaishya follow behind in that order, this is not a hierarchy of any kind. In
these modern times, the greedy businessman, who have plundered the wealth of
society with their shrewdness and dishonesty, they are commanding the highest
place and respect in the society. Thus they such businessman are causing social
chaos and disrupting the order. Let there be no doubt that, to fix such a rot,
an intense fight (संघर्ष) has to be launched. And, that struggle which
may perhaps demand the sacrifices of millions of people.
The second accusation against Varna Order is that, if older Varna-labels are
retained, then the new and refined order will again have the potential to degenerate over time and revert
to the older corrupt condition. But, this is a flawed thinking. The best way to
create a resistance against the older corrupted Varna
order is that, there must be revival and establishment of the
genuine-varna-order (सच्ची वर्ण व्यवस्था). If people continue to stay
divided in hundreds of groups even after crossing the barriers of
'jaat-paant' (जात-पांत), then what is the advantage of breaking
these 'jaat-paant' (जात-पांत). A single individual born in lower jaati,
if he can become an examplar (आदर्श) of the great Brahman (श्रेष्ठ
ब्रह्मण), then that would create a surge of strong emotions and powerful
advocacy against the barriers of 'jaat-paant' (जात-पांत).
Such a surge is not possible even with hundreds of advocacy speeches. Also,
when people will understand the harms caused by the barriers of
'jaat-paant' (जात-पांत) that is rooted in birth, then why would
they walk into the same trap again? The truth is that, we are unable to
break off the chains of the barriers of 'jaat-paant' (जात-पांत),
because we have failed to produce new genuine Brahmans, Kshatriyas and Vaishyas
that would be capable of replacing the degenerated old Brahmans,
Kshatriyas and Vaishyas. When a genuine currency/coin is brought into
circulation, the fake one looses out. Thus, it's a baseless doubt that, now
degenerated birth based Varna order
will catch up again, if we continue to use the varna-labels.
Still, the question still remains that, how to determine an individual's varna.
The answers is that, varna is
determined by that pledge (व्रत), which an individual has
made very early on in life (बाल्यावस्था). These are the
people who have received proper education and training in conformance to their
chosen varna. Such a choice is
either made by personal interest or based on a specialist advise. Also, one
must remember that, here specialization doesn't mean that, people of one varna
should never touch the work of another varna.
For example, if nation is under attack, or in the times of crisis, all should
be prepared for the Kshatriya duties. But, again people acquire mastery in the
work of one varna, and that
determines their varna.
One final accusation by the opponents of varna
order is that, may be this arrangement was useful once upon a time, but, in the
current times varna order is totally
worthless and harmful. Well, if people have completely discarded the genuine
varna order, and
instead rolled out an unjust and corrupted order, then its utterly unreasonable
(अनुचित)
to slander the genuine varna
order. It's also true that highly inequitable distribution of wealth has
created several major defects in the varna
order. But, no other social system has benefited the society, so much and
so long, as the varna
order did. Even today, with modest effort, this varna
order can again be fruitfully revived for the upliftment and wellbeing of the
society. This might be a more benevolent alternative to the capitalist and
communist systems. Genuine varna
order is such that, each and every individual of the society can fulfill their
life, while living a life that is useful for the society as well.
'Kaushal' (कौशल) - Mastery
Every
person can't acquire proficiency in world's all fields of knowledge and work.
Therefore, each person while having acquired general knowledge in relevant areas,
should acquire proficiency in a few specific subject matters. To this end,
three broad divisions of work have been created by the Indian Sages (ऋषि) and social scientists (समाज
वेत्ता).
A. One
category of work includes transforming natural resources into useful products
for the benefit of human life and living. Using their intellectual prowess and
physical labor, those who engage in this
pursuit of removing the impoverishment
of mankind, are called Vasishya (वैश्य).
B. Another category of work
involves maintaining order by forcefully righting the wrongs caused by human
weaknesses (मानव स्वभाव सुलभ दुर्बलता), e.g. greed,
anger, lust, jealousy, pride, prejudice etc., and that also demands spreading the
righteous/virtuous behavior (सद्व्यवहार). Those who acquire proficiency in this type of work of are
called Khstriya (क्षत्रिय).
C.
Acquisition of knowledge that is
beneficent for humanity in its entirety and committing oneself to
eliminate the ignorance (अविद्या) is yet another important category of work. Those who acquire proficiency in this field are called Brahman
(ब्राह्मण).
D. There is no
separate thing as 'darkness', in fact it's the absence of light.
Similarly, the absence of the mastery of any of the above three categories in
an individual, places an individual in the fourth Varna
of Shudra (शूद्र).
Work for each of the three Varna-categories, demand different
qualifications and specializations in individuals. A genuine Varna-Order also
champions that, everybody's basic necessities should be met, no matter which
category of work they engage in. Thus, people should receive fitting privileges
(यथायोग्य अधिकार) and remuneration (उचित दक्षिणा), in accordance with
the ease or difficulty of the work. Any social order that militates against
this fundamental principle, wouldn't help a society thrive. That's why the
Varna-order places special emphasis on people choosing that field of work in
which they are most suitably qualified. They can make this decision by
themselves after deep reflection. Or, they can seek help from other experts in
making the right choice and sharpen their skills to match their choices.
'Shakti-pratimaan' (शक्ति-प्रतिमान) - balanced
powerplay
How these people should conduct themselves in the society, after
having mastered the skills for the work, in accordance with their chosen varna
category? It's imperative to create a 'Code of conduct', for the society to
govern the interpersonal interactions and powerplay (शक्ति-प्रतिमान).
Varna Order is very crucial for balancing the powerplay within
the society. This ensures that various
types of powers should not get concentrated into the hands of a few
people. Four types of powers in the
society are used to exert influence. These are, shaastra (शास्त्र)
or the Gyan-shakti (ज्ञान-शक्ति), shastra (शस्त्र)
or armed force (सैन्य-बल), anna or wealth (अन्न या
संपत्ति) - food or wealth, and seva or labor force (सेवा या श्रमबल).
If a few people usurp all these powers,
then it will cause anarchy in the society. And People who command over these
huge concentrations of powers, their ego gets inflated monstrously and their
behavior turn dictatorial. Therefore, the genuine Varna Order,
prescribes a different reward and remuneration for these four categories of
powers.
By offering their services in the form of knowledge (ज्ञान
सेवा), Brahmans are given the high honor and respect of society. As a reward for protecting the society, Kshatriyas get
the privilege of governance (शासन).
Vaishyas generate wealth (धन) by fulfilling the needs of
the society like food etc. Sudra's needs are met in return for their service of
the three Varnas.
Removing ignorance (अज्ञान/अविद्या)
is most critical of above three
responsibilities. Because, without right knowledge, people can neither protect
society against injustice nor can they produce wealth by transforming natural resources
into useful products for the benefit of human life and living. Knowledge can produce
people of these two kinds, but these people can't create man making knowledge.
Thus all those people of nation, who are endowed with a harmonious blend of
knowledge (ज्ञान)
and self-restraint (संयम), they
should belong the first category, the
Brahman-Varna. If all people of a nation are equally talented (प्रतिभाशाली) and
who have total command over their senses (संयमी), then
such a nation is truly privileged and fortunate (भाग्यशाली). In
the comity of nations, it will speedily reach to the pinnacle of progress (उन्नति के शिखर). But,
until such a state is achieved, and until people naturally become a sustained
practitioner of self-restraint (आत्म-संयम के अभ्यासी), till such
time, we have a compelling need to create an social order/system, which
inspires and propels the human society on the path of achieving greatness (महानता). Thus
it becomes important that the people who can act as enabler, exemplar and
catalyst by sharing their knowledge with the society, they must be given
maximum respect and honor also. It's true that overcoming the craving for honor
(लोकेष्णा) is also a part of the practice of self-restraint (आत्म-संयम),
but, this state can only be achieved over time. Therefore, to begin with,
people of this category must be given maximum respect and honor, this will
inspire nation's best and brightest children to follow their example. Although,
people in this category may not crave for external respect (लौकिक मान), but
it is important that nation offers special honor to such people who really
don't demand it. Thus, everyone gets inspiration to inculcate such a great virtue (सद्गुण).
But,
one must not forget that, there is a limit for self-restraint (आत्म-संयम की सीमा). For developing high proficiency, as it is necessary to
categorize the people, similarly, for the success of each group, they must be
treated well with respect. At the same time, there should be enough safeguards
to prevent the concentration of power and wealth in the hands of one group.
Otherwise, they would tend to ignore the larger good of the society and indulge
in dictatorial behavior. Whenever, any group that acquires unchecked and
limitless power, their fall is certain. That's why someone said, "Power
tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely." That's why
Indian social scientists created the Varna order such that, the self correcting
order keeps each other in mutual check and balance for proper functioning of
the society. That's called the 'Shakti-pratimaan' (शक्ति-प्रतिमान) or
balanced powerplay.
'Yathaayogya-Dakshinaa' (यथा-योग्य दक्षिणा) - just remuneration
In almost all social orders
prevailing world over, money is the primary form of compensation for the work
product or service provided by an individual. We feel satisfied that we have
provided just remuneration (यथा-योग्य दक्षिणा), when
we pay varying amounts of money which is commensurate with the work and
qualification of the service provider. But, when giving remuneration according
to Varna order, we have to think
that whatever we offer as compensation, should also be useful (उपयोगी)
for the recipient. Well, now one can forward an argument that, when
money can buy goods and services, then why not use money itself for remuneration
(दक्षिणा)?
But, one flaw in doing so is that, the importance of money is glorified too
much, which then disrupts the 'Shakti-pratimaan' (शक्ति-प्रतिमान) or
balanced powerplay. That's why according to Varna
order, Brahmans are entitled to the sadhana of knowledge (ज्ञान वृद्धि
की साधना) and puja. Kshatriya are given charge of governance. And, Vaishyas
are custodians of the worldly wealth (सांसारिक वैभव). That's what
makes fitting remuneration (यथा-योग्य दक्षिणा) of these three Varnas.
And, that system alone can
enhance the social balance, happiness and peace (संतुलन,
सुख और शांति).
'Adhikar bhed'
(अधिकार-भेद)
- differential qualifications & worthiness
For different categories of people,
Dharma-Shastras (धर्म-शास्त्र) have provided different
teachings/lessons (शिक्षाएँ). Somewhere, Shastras paint the horrors of
narak (नरक),
sufferings of 8.4 millions life forms (चौरासी लाख योनियाँ), and the fear of Ishvariya Dand (ईश्वरीय
दंड). On the other hand Dharma-shastras create an anticipation (प्रलोभन)
that, Ishvar Kripaa (ईश्वर कृपा) will bestow, wealth (धन),
progeny (संतान),
prosperity (ऐश्वर्य), happiness (सुख/आनंद),
svarg (स्वर्ग),
moksh (मोक्ष)
etc. Whereas at another place, these Shastras expound this tatva-gyan (तत्व-ज्ञान)
of the blissfully experiencing the 'Sachchidaanand-svaroop' (सच्चिदानंद
स्वरूप) of Atma (आत्मा), ecstasy of samadhi (समाधि आनंद)
and achievement of 'Param-pad' (परम-पद). This leaves people
puzzled that why there are so many contradictory teaching (उपदेश) given
in the Shastras? But, when we examine in depth, it's found that this diversity
of teachings reflect a essential unity. Depending on the qualifications and
worthiness (अधिकार-भेद), different people are given
different-different types of lessons for action (भिन्न-भिन्न कर्मोपदेश). Animals work only by force (पशुओं
को केवल दंड के द्वारा ही काम में
लगाया जा सकता है). Someone can move a herd of sheep from one place to
another, only with the help of stick. If you try to convince the herd and tell them to walk on the street in a
single file, they would neither understand what you said nor would the follow
any of your sweet words. There are many among humans, who belong to such animal
like category. Such animal like people, can only be made to follow righteous
path (सन्मार्ग), by use of force and control.
We can't hope that, without such use of force, punishment and fear, the thieves,
rapists, murderers, terrorists etc. would voluntarily follow the righteous
path.
The people in medium category (मध्यम-श्रेणी), are those, who
can perceive their interest and loss (हित-अहित). Potentially they can be persuaded on
the righteous path, if one moves their
hearts with love, and also makes them understand the ups and down of their
choices. If they are shown fear of punishment, such people will simply revolt
and go against the advice. Love is the only 'weapon', that's effective on them.
It's love (प्रेम), rather than punishment (दंड), that solves the family disputes.
Then there are those who are intellectuals (विचारक), who possess a
contemplative and intuitive mind (उच्च-मनोभूमि),
and whose Atma is enlightened (प्रबुद्ध-आत्मा), for them, just
suggestion (संकेत) is enough (पर्याप्त). They can
recognize their mistakes by a mere pointer, and then, without loosing a single
moment they get cautioned and start correcting their course.
Thus,in reality, Truth (सत्य) is only One, but depending on the qualifications
and worthiness (अधिकार-भेद), the same Truth is applied in three
different ways. That's why Truth is also given the name of Satya (सत्य),
Prem (प्रेम),
and Nyaya (न्याय). One should evaluate the level of the students
and calibrate their lessons accordingly. Different type of people deserve
different type of interaction/behavior (व्यवहार). Some can be
persuaded on righteous path by Truth (सत्य), others by love (प्रेम)
and the rest by 'Nyaa-dand' (न्याय-दंड). Thus, people on the
path of 'Satya-Dharma' (सत्य-धर्म के अनुयायी), have to
choose different path for themselves. Hindu Varna Order represents this choice
(हिन्दू धर्म की वर्ण व्यस्था इसी चुनाव की बोधक है). Whoever has interest and
aptitude in specific subject matter, they can accept that field. Those whose
mental makeup (मनोभूमि) is receptive and responsive (उपयुक्त)
to Satya (सत्य), they are the Brahmans. Those who have a mental
makeup soaked with love (प्रेम पूरित मन),
they are the Vaishyas. And, those who are concerned with justice and power (न्याय
एवं शक्ति), they are the Kshatriyas. But, one must note that such
propensities of mind (मानसिक प्रवृत्तियां) do not evolve in one day. Past
'prarabdh-karma' (प्रारब्ध कर्म), accumulated intuitive convictions (संचित
विश्वास), and the long-term sanskaars of knowledge and ignorance (ज्ञान
एवं अज्ञान संस्कार), these are the drivers that create the building
blocks and establish the foundation of Brahmanhood (ब्राह्मणत्व),
khsatriyahood (क्षत्रियत्व), and vaishyahood (वैश्यत्व). Very
often people have the dominant traits (गुण) of the family in
which they are born. But, sometimes there exists the variation between the
habits (स्वभाव)
of 'janma and karma' (जन्म एवं कर्म), which are caused by the strong influence of sanskars
(संस्कारों
की प्रबलता). Finally, it's the life habit and sanskars which hold
primacy. For example, due to their
sanskars and despite the circumstance of their birth/family, Vashishtha,
Satyakama, Ramanuj, Vishwamitra, and Gautambuddha, all these achieved
Brahmanhood. Dronacharya, Kripacharya and Parashuram, although born in Brahman
families, became Kshatriyas due to their dominant sanskars. Similarily, there
are instances of the vaishya's changing varna
too.
'Adhyaatmik Varna' (आध्यात्मिक वर्ण) - spiritual varna
Satya (सत्य),
Prem (प्रेम),
Nyaya (न्याय),
whatever dominates our core interest (विशेष रूचि), and that which suits
our mental makeup (योग्य मनोभूमि), accordingly, we have to choose our varna.
It's immaterial even if our social/external varna
(भौतिक
वर्ण) continues to be derived from our birth. As driven by the dominant
sanskars (संस्कारों की प्रबलता) and the inclination of mind (मानसिक
रूचि/आकर्षण), accordingly we
can still choose our spiritual varna
(आध्यात्मिक
वर्ण).
Just as people have a given name and one nick name too, likewise, it
doesn't matter if we keep two varnas also. One external varna
(भौतिक
वर्ण) and another spiritual varna
(आध्यात्मिक
वर्ण). The real deal is that, one must adopt their behavior in
conformance to the chosen varna and
encourage others also to follow their example. By following either one, we can
achieve the ultimate goal.
Now, people may ask that, this discussion has only covered three varnas, why we
have left out the fourth varna.
In this context, my considered opinion is that, just like there is no
such thing called 'darkness' (अन्धेरा), rather it's merely a
condition caused by absence of light (प्रकाश का अभाव). Just as the
absence of life (जीवन का अभाव), is called death (मृत्यु). Extending
this analogy, Shudrahood (शूद्रत्व) is merely the absence
of the qualities of above three varnas (तीन वर्णों के गुणों का अभाव), and it's the absence of the three varna-dharmas
(तीन वर्णों के धर्म का अभाव). An individual whose state of
mind is dull/inert (जड़ मनोभूमि), who neither knows nor strives to
achieve 'satya-prem-nyaya' (सत्य-प्रेम-न्याय), that is a the
Shudra in real sense. From this viewpoint, Shudrahood (शूद्रत्व),
is a sort of blemish on humanity (मनुष्यता का अभिशाप). Anyone
should feel embarrassed/ashamed while calling himself a Shudra, because this
word is nearly indicative of the animal existence (पशुत्व का
बोधक). Initially, when they are without knowledge (ज्ञान से
रहित), all people are named Shudra. But, when they enter into the knowledge/learning
(ज्ञान
में प्रवेश), then they cast off this spiritual garb of Shudrahood (शूद्रत्व
का अध्यात्मिक चोला). The three varnas of Brahman, Kshatrya and Vaishya
are called 'dvija' (द्विज) or 'dvijanma' (द्विजन्मा). That
is they have all cast off their old shudrahood (शूद्रत्व),
thus they have acquired the new birth/body of human greatness (मानवीय
उच्चता का शरीर). Shudras become 'dvija' (द्विज)
by receiving 'diksha' (दीक्षा), and wearing three threaded 'yagyopaveet' (यज्ञोपवीत). To achieve spiritual dvijatva (आध्यात्मिक
द्विजत्व), is the prime duty and key endeavor of every human being.
Those who neglect this duty,
they continue to spend their life in Shudrahood and such a wasteful life and wasted
opportunity is totally condemnable (सर्वथा धिक्कारने योग्य).
Varna Order in Vedas, Gita, Mahabharat &
Manusmriti
Indian Civilization in its social
dimensions also stands on rational/scientific foundation. Indian intelligentsia
(भारतीय
तत्वज्ञानी) created highly beneficial social order and tradition for
Hindu people. Which gave tremendous advantage to Hindus and helped them
preserve their precious Civilization despite external attacks from Arabian, Persian and European invaders, raiders and plunderers.
In contrast, many world civilizations have been
wiped out from the map due to attacks by these very same forces.
Well, Indian scriptures pronounce
that "आचारः परमो धर्म" (life behavior is the ultimate Dharma). In Hindu civilization,
those principles have prime importance, which not only raise us morally and
spiritually, but also help uplift our social life as well. Current times are
time of transition (संक्रांति) and clash (संघर्ष). If
we Indians want to preserve our Civilization (आचार-परम्परा), then we must weed out the defects
that got entrenched in our civilization. Also, we must practice with complete श्रद्धा,
the traditions (परिपाटी) established by our Sages, forefather and
Rishis.
The bedrock of the foundation of India's
society is सदाचार (sadachar, the life behavior embedded with
Truth). That's why the first Sutra (सूत्र) used to explain its
Dharma proclaims "आचारः परमो धर्म" (Acharah Prathamo Dharm). Our
society has functioned on four Varna-Order (वर्ण व्यस्था) and four Ashram
traditions (आश्रम परंपरा). Here, we will briefly review the merits of this social
arrangement from the perspective of Dharma Shastras:
'Chaturvarna'
(चतुर्वर्ण) - The Four Varnas
Vedas have specified Varna Order.
Entire society is organized in four Varnas of Brahman, Kshatriya, Vaishya and
Shudra. The whole purpose is that each varna
performs their duties with masterful skills and efficiency in
cooperation/collaboration with other varnas. If a person does perform a
specific type of work with full dedication, then he can achieve proficiency and
specialization. By continuously changing work, one doesn't benefit and can't
produce high quality work product. That's why Vedas specify, different type of
work for each of the four varnas. Here are some direct quotes on what Dharma-Shastra
say about Varna-Order.
Yajurveda
ch.38, verse.14 (page 38.3):
{Rishi - Dirghatamaa (ऋषि दीर्घतमा) ,
Devata - Dharma, Khar (देवता - धर्म, खर)}
इषे पिन्वस्वोर्जे पिन्वस्व ब्रह्मणे पिन्वस्व क्षत्राय पिन्वस्व द्यावापृथिवीभ्यां पिन्वस्व |
धर्मासि सुधर्मामेन्यस्मे नृम्णानि धारय ब्रह्म धारय क्षत्रं धारय विशं धारय
||३८-१४||
हे यज्ञ देव ! अन्न की वृद्धि तथा बल-पराक्रम के लिये सम्पूर्ण प्रजा को आप पुष्ट बनाएं |
ब्राह्मणत्व तथा क्षत्रियत्व की वृद्धि के लिये प्रजा को पुष्ट बनाएं |
द्युलोक और पृथिवी लोक के विस्तार के लिये प्रजा पुष्ट हो |
हे परमात्मन् ! आप उत्तम रीति से समस्त प्रजा एवं राष्ट्र को धारण करने में समर्थ हैं | आप हिंसारहित हैं | मनुष्यों के लिये हितकारी ऐश्वर्य हमें प्रदान करें !
आप हमें ब्राह्मणत्व, क्षत्रियत्व तथा
व्यापार की क्षमता प्रदान करें ||
O ! Yagya Dev ! invigorate all
people to grow food and to increase strength and valor.
Invigorate people to invigorate and
enhance Brahmanatva (ब्राह्मणत्व) and Khsatriyatva (क्षत्रियत्व
).
May you invigorate people for the
expansion of Dhyuloka (द्युलोक) and Prithiviloka (पृथिवी
लोक).
O ! Parmatman (परमात्मन्)
! You are capable (समर्थ) to bear (धारण) the nation (राष्ट्र)
and its people in the best way (उत्तम रीति). You are devoid of
violence. Bestow upon us that Aishwarya (ऐश्वर्य), which is
beneficent for human kind.
You bestow upon us the Brahmanhood (ब्राह्मणत्व),
Kshatriyahood (क्षत्रियत्व ) and the ability of trade (व्यापार ),
the Vaishyahood (वैश्यत्व).
{Commentary by Vedmurti
Taponishtha Pt. Shriram
Sharma Acharya}
Rigveda
(Mandala.10,
Sukta.90, verse.12)
{ Rishi - Narayan (नारायण), Devata -
Purush (पुरुष)}
Same verse repeats in Yajurveda ch.31, verse.11 (page 31.2):
{ Rishi - Narayan Purush (नारायण पुरुष), Devata - Purush Jagadbeej (पुरुष जगद्बीज)}
ब्राह्मणोस्य
मुखमासीद्बाहू राजन्यः कृतः |
उरू तदस्य
यद्वैश्यः पदभ्या शूद्रो अजायत ||
“Brahmano asya Mukhamaseed bhahu
Rajanyah Kritaha
Uru tadasya yad vaishyah, padabhyam
shudro ajaayata”.
विराट
पुरुष का मुख ब्राह्मण (ज्ञानीजन) हुए,
क्षत्रिय (पराक्रमी व्यक्ति), उसके शरीर में विद्यमान बाहुओं के सामान हैं |
वैश्य अर्थात् पोषण शक्ति संपन्न व्यक्ति उसके जंघा एवं
शूद्र अर्थात् सेवाधर्मी व्यक्ति, उसके पैर हुए ||११||
The mouth of Viraat Purush (विराट पुरुष) became
Brahman (ब्राह्मण) (Knowledge operatives/ ज्ञानीजन),
the hands in the body of Viraat Purush (विराट पुरुष)
are like Kshatriya (people of valor) क्षत्रिय
(पराक्रमी व्यक्ति)|
Uppar legs (thighs)
in the body of Viraat Purush (विराट पुरुष) are like Vaishya
(people capable of providing sustenance to society) (वैश्य
अर्थात् पोषण शक्ति
संपन्न व्यक्ति), and the the feet in the body of
Viraat Purush (विराट पुरुष) are like Shudra (service oriented
people) (शूद्र अर्थात् सेवाधर्मी
व्यक्ति)|
{Commentary by Vedmurti
Taponishtha Pt. Shriram Sharma Acharya}
Brahman's main function is teaching
with use of speech, thus their origin is attributed to the mouth of the
'Viraat-purush' (विराट पुरुष). Hands/arms are a symbol of might and
Kshatriya carry weapons, they govern and protect the nation, thus their origin
is deemed to be from the hands of the 'Viraat-purush' (विराट पुरुष).
Legs/thighs represent strength and vigor (बलिष्ठता एवं पौरुष).
These qualities are required for farming and trade/production. Thus, Vaishya's
origin is regarded to be from the Legs/thighs of the 'Viraat-purush' (विराट
पुरुष). The feet carry the load of whole body. Like wise Shudras, by
their seva (सेवा), contribute towards smooth functioning of the
society. As if they carry the load of society. So, their origin is imagined
from the feet of 'Viraat-purush' (विराट
पुरुष).
Just like all these body parts
(mouth, hands, thighs, and feet) have distinct natural form, function and
characteristics, still they collaboratively, cooperatively and harmoniously function within the body as
a whole. None of these body parts dominate the functioning of the body. Rather,
their seemingly independent operation stems from being different parts of a
single body. Thus, origin of four Varnas from the different parts of the body
of 'Viraat-purush' (विराट पुरुष), clearly points to the foundation of Varna
order on the basis of different 'guna-karma-svabhav' (गुण-कर्म-स्वभाव).
Gita
Varna Order in following verse (4-13):
चातुर्वर्ण्यं
मया सृष्टं गुणकर्मविभागशः ।
तस्य कर्तारमपि मां विद्ध्यकर्तारमव्ययम् ॥ ४-१३ ॥
गुण और कर्मों के भेद/विभाग पूर्वक चार वर्ण
(ब्राह्मण, क्षत्रिय, वैश्य और शूद्र) मैंने रचे हैं। इस
प्रकार उस सृष्टि-रचनादि कर्मका कर्ता होनेपर भी तू मुझे अकर्ता-अविकारी ही जान।
Bhagwan
Sri Krishna, thus determines Varna Order on the basis of differentiation in
man's intrinsic qualities (गुण), actions (कर्म) and habits (स्वभाव).
Mahabharat,
A dialogue between Yudhishthir and
Yaksha mentions that:
"Man neither
becomes Brahman by birth, nor by the knowledge of Vedas alone. By high
character (उच्च चरित्र), only one is recognized as a
Brahman."
In the Mahabharat period, varna
order was in vogue. Mahabharat describes the duties of four varnas in many
places (see Mahabharat Adiparva 64/8/34). Mahabharat also narrates how the
people of all varnas were engaging in duties according to their respective
varnas. Dharma doesn't diminish when people follow their varna
Dharma and adopt their life behavior accordingly (Mahabharat Adiparva 64-24).
In 'Shanti-parva' of Mahabharat,
Maharshi Bhrigu (महर्षि-भृगु), explains to his disciple Bharadwaj (भारद्वाज)
that, in the beginning there existed only one Varna,
the Brahman varna. Later, this got
divided into four. Bhrigu, clearly attributes the origin of varnas to
'guna-karma-svabhava' (गुण-कर्म-स्वभाव), rather than some new
differentiating factor.
Manusmriti
"विप्राणां
ज्ञानतो ज्येष्ठं क्षत्रियाणां तु वीर्यतः" .
That means, Brahman commands
respect by knowledge (ज्ञान) and Kshatriya by valor and vigor (बल-वीर्य).
Pancha-Adhyaayi (पंचाध्यायी)
Primary determinant of man's Varna are his intrinsic qualities (गुण), actions (कर्म) and habits (स्वभाव).
लोकस्तु
जन्मना सर्वः शूद्र एवाभिजायते |
संस्कारैरभिजायान्ते
पश्चात्सर्वे द्विजायतः||
By birth the whole world is Shudra. Thereafter, by Sanskar (संस्कार), one become dvija (द्विज).
Duties of various Varnas
A Brahman is one who is committed to use his knowledge to remove
society's the ignorance and inertia (अज्ञान और मूढ़ता निवारण).
One who is committed to protect the society from aggression and
injustice is Kshatriya.
Viahsya is one who is committed to the prosperity and sustenance
of society through operating a fair supply chain and production.
In fact Shudra is the one who doesn't possess ability to work
independently due to lack of intellect, wisdom and farsightedness. Thus people
of Shudra varna can only provide help and service to the
other three varnas. Which may include unskilled jobs.
To meet the needs of an efficiently functioning society, and keeping in
view the differentiation of Guna and Karma, the Varna order is evolved by the Indian sages.
Current degenerated state of Varna
Order
When we see today's rotten form of Varna Order, it's not that principles are at fault, rather it's people's
ignorance and their wrong actions responsible for this distortion. Varna Order
teaches that, we should live our lives with a specific goal in mind.
Unfortunately, over time this varna order got fossilized and hardened to the
extent that varna order is lately being dominated by birth/family
position. This is absolutely erroneous social condition, needing immediate
correction. In realty, people should get work according to their varna as determined by their Guna and Karma.
And, they should receive the social reorganization accordingly. Those people
who do not possess the Guna and Karma appropriate for their Varna, they should not become member of such varna and move into a suitable Varna. Puranas mention the transition of this
type. For example, Vishwamitra was born a Kshatriya, but he grew into Brahman varna on the basis of his knowledge, intellect,
sadhana and high cultural values (उच्च सांस्कृतिक वैभव).
Varna
order is thus meant to be for distribution of work, but today this has
degenerated and the system is being misused and abused to the detriment of the
socirty. Now one can find multitude of Upa-jaati (उपजाति). Among
Brahmans alone, there are almost 2000 sub-identities. 'Sarasvat-Brahman' alone
have 649 branches. Kshatriya's have 990 branches. Vaishya and Shudra have many
more Upa-jaati (उपजाति). This state of social affairs has almost
destroyed the India's
cultural unity (सांस्कृतिक एकता). Only Guna and Karma are the genuine
measure of a person and accordingly he should be given respect in the
society. It's not the birth, rather Guna, that should command society's
respect. If an individual from Shudra varna
grows his ability, knowledge and intellect, then he should also command the
same respect as a Brahman does. No one should be excluded on the basis of
birth.
Despite being of unknown varna,
Jabali's son Satyakaam was considered to be worthy of 'Brahm-Vidya' (ब्रह्म-विद्या)
due to his Guna of Truthfulness (सत्यवक्ता). Thus
the petty narrowness of currently degenerated Jati tradition is worth
abandoning. And, guna-karma-swabhav (गुण-कर्म-स्वभाव) should be re-established
as the primary determinant of an individual's Varna.
Gita
and Future Varna Order (गीता और भावी वर्ण व्यस्था)
At the time, when Gita was told by
Bhagvan Sri Krishna, Indian society was divided into four Varnas. As a result
of this the various Jaati-dharma or Jati-karma were inharited naturally (जन्म-सिद्ध
) by the people . In additiona to the four Varnas of Brahman, Khsatriy,
Vaishya and Shudra, there were some "Papa-yoni" Jaatis (पाप-योनी
जातियां), like there were dog-eater 'Chandaals' too. According to Gita,
in that specific time, whatever work came in the way of a specific Jati,
they deemed it to be the right fit. Not only this, Gita goes even further and says
that giving up our dhrama (स्वधर्म) and taking up others
dharma (परधर्म),
is inappropriate and a matter of extreme fear. Such behavior may be harmful to the social order.
The point to ponder is that, whether this ancient Varna-order is always going
to remain invariable (अटल) and always going to prevail, no matter what was
the social order in the Gita-period, and no matter how much change happend in
place-and-time (देश-काल) since then? Gita itself doesn't offer any
such guarantee ! Gita prescribed this Varna
order for a time period when people of all the four Varnas truly practiced
their own dharma. Not only that, more a Varna
was considered worthy of honor and veneration, they carried higher
responsibilities. Brahmans were deemed to be worthy of high honor, their right
to material comforts (इन्द्रिय-सुख), was the least of all. Total command
over internal and external senses (इन्द्रिय-संयम), was core of a
Brahmin's primary code of conduct. When we survey the society of the
Gita-period, there is no such prominent Brahman to be found, who had amassed huge
wealth or who has indulged in the luxuries of life. Although, Kshatriyas
had the power to rule, they always have to be ready to sacrifice their lives
for the protection of their subjects and nation. In those days, getting a bad
name (अपयश)
by loosing was considered to be worse than going down fighting. That's why no
Kshatriya would show their back in the battle field. That's why Gita describes
ten duties for a Brahman, seven for Kshatriya, three for Vaishya and only one
duty for Shudra. The balance between responsibilities and honor was maintained
such that no single Varna would
dominate the social order. That's why, in the 'Vibhuti Yoga' of Gita while
describing the four Varnas, Bhagvan Sri Krishna nowhere said 'Varnaam
Brahmanoamyaham' (वर्णानां ब्राह्मणोऽम्यहम्). Means
he never said that that 'I am Brahman among the four Varnas'.
In today's time people who claim to
be of higher Varna, they only hanker
for honor/respect but run away from associated
responsibility and constraints of duties. How could that be possible to command
respect without bearing commensurate responsibilities and duties. For the benevolence of society, today, Brahmans
don't use their knowledge (विद्या), Kshatriya don't use
their strength/clout, and Vaishyas don't use their wealth. They all have given
up their responsibilities of their Varna-Dharma. Today's biggest need is
that even the smallest people of the society should be treated with honor and
given equitable rights in the society. Until we bring to bear the principles of
justice and equality, we can not expect the creation of a good and harmonious
social order. When we get rid of the unnatural inequality (अस्वाभाविक
असमानता), and bring the order of equality in consonant with the nature,
only then people's natural tendencies (स्वाभाविक प्रवृत्ति) can
be used to determine their actions (कर्म). Firstly, in such a natural
condition, an individual can himself make this determination. If he faces
difficulties in making the right choice of work, then he can seek guidance from
experienced teachers (अनुभवी गुरुजन). When
people intuitively feel the natural social equality, then there will be no
prejudice about the superiority or inferiority of different types of work
available in the society. Similarly, when all people can earn their livelihood
and achieve an equitable and comfortable standard of living, then no one would
think that which work will fetch them more money. At this stage, all that
matters is to choose the work for which we have the best skill set and best
ability. When, we are able to pick a work that matches our interest and nature
(रूचि
और स्वभाव), then there would be no fear of failure or falling behind.
Prior to creating a new social order, it is imperative that we fix the current dispensation so that all type of
work commands equal respect and brings financial equality (प्रतिष्ठा और आर्थिक समता). This appears to be difficult, but we can kill the inequality by commanding our senses (इन्द्रिय
संयम). This is what
Gitaakaar says, "काम एष क्रोध एष रजोगुण
समुद्भवः ! महाशनो महापाप्मा विद्धयेनमिह वैरिणम !! (गीता ३/३७)"
(kaam, esha, krodha esha,
rajoguna samudbhavah). Our ancestors have demonstrated by their own life and clearly instructed us to live by the ideas of
"आत्मवत सर्व भूतेषु" (Atmvat Sarva Bhooteshu),
and "आत्मौपम्ये सर्वत्र समं पश्यति" (Atmaupamye sarvatra samam pashyati). Thefefore, no
reason stops us from emulating their example. Due to our unstable minds (चंचल
मन), like that of Arjun, we too may find it difficult in the beginning
to practice the 'Samya-Yoga' (साम्य-योग). But we must bring
this in our lives by persistent effort (अभ्यास), detachment (वैराग्य),
and command of senses (संयम).
Varna Order for New Era (नवयुग
के अनुरूप वर्ण-व्यवस्था)
For
organizing a well functioning
society, in ancient times, the Indian Sages and thinkers (ऋषि-मनीषी), felt the need of Varna Order
(वर्ण-व्यवस्था). Shudra
category of people were entrusted with the service activities (सेवा-कार्य). Vaishya category of people were responsible for running an efficient supply
chain and trade/commerce. Kshatriya category of people took upon their shoulders the responsibility of governance, defense,
warfare (युद्ध-विद्या) related pursuits (पुरुषार्थ) and heroism (पराक्रम). While Brahmans dedicated themselves for the diffusion of knowledge (सद्ज्ञान
का प्रसार), altruistic service
(पुण्य/परमार्थ), and welfare of society (लोकमंगल).
People of all these four
categories, maintained an effective social order (समाज
व्यस्था) by mutual
collaboration and cooperation.
There was no conflict among people of different
categories, and thus prevailed an environment rich in Satogun (सतोगुण), a Satyugi milieu (सतयुगी
वातावरण) dominated the
society. That was such a time that mere imagination of which makes people euphoric (पुलकित) even today.
These four categories exist today also, but due to distortion,
corruption and onslaught
of over a millennium, now these seem to be causing disorder and stink, instead of inspiring people and uplifting
the society.
In
Manusmriti, Bhagwan Manu has
described all human beings as Shudra at birth. And, says that by performance of their duties only, people earn entry into next Varnas. If we survey today's
world, we will find that most
people belong to Shudra Varna. Manu designated all human beings as Shudra at birth, because, in its initial
phases of life human consciousness
is extremely limited and constricted (सीमित एवं संकुचित), thus individual remains self-centered (आत्म-केन्द्रित).
Like lower creatures, he is just focused on 'me and
mine'. His thought processed don't jump
beyond this circle of me and mine'. But, later in life when he come
in contact of society, then, he starts
thinking about giving back (प्रतिदान) and repaying his debt to the society (उऋण). Now, when he engages cooperatively in the activities of Seva (सेवा-सहकार), then he is becomes eligible for entry into the next Varna. In the ancient times, those people who
engaged in
Seva-activities, were called
Shudra. But, now people who are loath Seva-activities (सेवा-विमुख), are kept in the Shudra category.
There
is no shortage of people in
the Vaishya category, even today. In ancient times, Vaishyas were responsible for farming and food production, providing food to hungry and
clothe the naked. Putting it differently,
Vaishyas were the people with inclination and passion for self-less service
(परमार्थी-प्रकृति). Vaishyas
were
always at the
forefront to offer their wealth and resources for the works of social wellbeing (सामाजिक
कार्य). But, in the current
times,
Vaishyas have developed a greedy
tendency and hoarding mentality (संचयजन्य मनोवृत्ति). Now they are in rat-race for materialistic luxuries (भौतिकता) and physical comforts (ऐश-ओ-आराम). Still, there exist many generous Vaishyas, who remind of
the 'Rishi-Yug' (ऋषि-युग). Therefore,
according to today's behavior pattern, they are termed Vaishyas. Vaishya-vritti (वैश्य-वृत्ति)
of ancient times was hallmark
of
the renunciation of 'Sanchaya-vritti'
(संचय-वृत्ति)
or greedy/hoarding mentality.
Today, this
Vaishya-vritti (वैश्य-वृत्ति)
is very rare, and only to be
found in dream (स्वप्नवत).
Kshatriyatva (क्षत्रियत्व), is defined by valor and heroism (पुरुषार्थ-पराक्रम).
Kshatriya means a courage (साहस)
to inspire people to change the society. Putting down the injustice and
wickedness was also a part of Kshatriya's
job description. But, it appears that today's Kshatriyas have become void of virility (पुरुषत्वहीन).
They can neither raise
themselves
nor somebody else. Rather,
they seem to be conspiring for abasement, torture and exploitation
(गिराने, सताने
एवं शोषण करने). This is how
they hold their reign of power (प्रभुत्व).
This is what they think is their valor and heroism (पुरुषार्थ-पराक्रम). If they wanted, Kshatriyas could use power and influence, to completely turn
around and re-create a whole new social order sans today's social defects. They could have played a vital role in transforming this society,
anew ! But, shunning such critical
responsibility attendant upon a Kshatriya role, they are only blemishing (कलंकित) their Kshatriyhood/Kshatriyatva (क्षत्रियत्व).
Although, they have ambition
for power and influence (प्रभुता एवं वर्चस्व), they fail to demonstrate Kshatriya-drive
(पुरुषार्थ).
Renewal of this Kshatriya-drive (पुरुषार्थ) is the main need of today.
The Brahman category commanded highest respect, because their work was more precious and important in comparison
to the Kshatriyas and Vaishyas. Brahmans
shunned their personal ambitions (महत्वाकांक्षा), lived at the level of an average citizen, and stayed engaged
in the altruistic self-less pursuits (परमार्थ-प्रयोजन), and they offered truthful advice
(सत्परामर्श) to the society.
From one vantage point, such a Brahmanhood was the ultimate outcome of human qualities (मानवीय
गुणों की चरम परिणिति). That
was the highest stage of human development, because in that state compassion (करुणा)
and intuitive emotions (भाव-संवेदना)
expand to such a degree that,
entire world feels like a one family to them. Where nobody is other, and nobody is own.
Thinking the whole world as his own family, a Brahman engages in counseling (मार्ग-दर्शन
), and Daan-Punya' (दान-पुण्य) for the society's wellbeing (कल्याण).
Such a Brahmanhood/Brahmanatva (ब्राह्मणत्व)
is also a rare occurrence
these
days.
Today, we should
strive to achieve Brahmanhood, but we need not completely ignore the duties of Shudra, Vaishya and
Kshatriya also. Shudra karma means the
Seva of 'Viraat-Brahm' (विराट ब्रह्म), the whole manifest-universe. Vaishya
karma means getting rid of our habit of greed and tame the tendency to accumulate wealth by generous contributions
towards society's wellbeing.
Courage (साहस),
valor (पराक्रम),
righteous anger/Manyu (मन्यु), and rage against injustice (अनीति के प्रति आक्रोश), these are the characteristics of a Kshatriya. These
three duties of Shudra,
Vaishya and Kshatriya, should be born simultaneously these days. This is the clarion call of Mahakal (महाकाल की पुकार). This is also His grand desire (महत इच्छा) and His aspiration (आकांक्षा) too.
Towards
Brahmanhood (ब्राह्मणत्व)
All philosophers till date held the
view that human form is the best living form in the world. But, relatively
speaking all human are not at the same level. They all differ in their thought
processes (विचार-प्रणाली), object attachment (विषय-प्रवृत्ति),
motivational elements (प्रेरक-तत्व), work execution (कार्य-संचालन),
intellectual prowess (बुद्धि-वैभव), and physical wealth (शारीरिक-संपत्ति).
Everyone has earned wealth which is never same for all. Even when
exactly similar opportunities are available, people turn out differently, not
identical. Children born to same parents are seen to have opposing qualities.
Students of the same Guru are seen to have varying degree of knowledge. Neither
any evidence nor logic is necessary to prove the extreme diversity of our
world. That is self-evident. And, this diversity is seen among humans as well.
In comparison to other living
creatures, humans are superior only due to their intellectual profusion (बुद्धि-वैभव).
Thus intellectual riches are the key determinants of human's varying
levels. Some people while possessing sharp intellect, do not use it. Rather,
they yield to be controlled my other's intellect, almost robotically (यंत्रवत).
Such people merely become an instrument for others work, but they can't
do their own work. Therefore, such people can't develop their own independent
personality. They only make living from whatever they earn by
working for their employers. The limit of their existence is only food, sleep,
fear and mating. They can't achieve the glory of a free thinking (स्वतंत्रचेता)
person, which is only possible by rising beyond such mundane existence
driven by these base instincts. People like these are pronounced the Shudra in
the Varna order (वर्ण-मर्यादा)
of the Arya Sanskriti (आर्य-संस्कृति). Physical labor
(शारीरिक
श्रम ) and hard bodily tapas (कठोर दैहिक तप) is the
distinctive characteristic of them. That's what is the essence of the Vedic
saying 'तपसे
शूद्रम्' (tapse Shudram).
Above this level, there is another
category of people that although do physical labor, but their goal is to
fulfill their own needs. For example, farmer grows crops and raises cattle.
Trader engages in business activities. But, they do it all for themselves, not
for anybody else. To perform these activities they endure hardship (कठोर
तप). They face the turmoil of cold, heat, comfort and hardship, but
objective is their own wellbeing (स्वयं का हित). That's the only
difference between people at this level (वैश्य) and
the one described earlier (शूद्र). The
difference of intellectual pursuit (बुद्धि की
क्रियाशीलता) accounts for For
this difference of levels. Without use of intellect neither a person can benefit from
agriculture nor take advantage of trade and business. If one doesn't use his
intellect, then he merely becomes a means to someone else's ends. It's the
active intellect that saves people from merely becoming an instrument in the
hands of others. This is the level of Vaishya category.
The third level is of the people
who use their intellect more relative to the Vaishya category. They take up the
responsibility of protecting the society, for which they have to think and
implement a variety of solutions. They have to be aware of and stay alert from
the multitude of threats originating from external and internal sources. They
have to gather and process intelligence related to enemy's conspiracies and promptly
act upon them. They are also responsible to organize defenses and earn
proficiency in operating these systems effectively. These are some of the
things this group needs to gain proficiency in. This work also requires
physical hard work and hardship, but with higher degree of intellectual power,
in comparison to the first two levels.
However, there is a huge difference
in the goals when it come to this third level of people. The goal of Vaishya
group is their own benefit. But, goal of this third group is the protection of
their society. While a Shudra, without much intellectual activity, only serves
one or few people, this third group serves the whole nation/society with his
higher degree of intellectual prowess. Thus, from many points of view,
this third group of people stands superior, relative to the earlier two groups
of Vaishya and Shudra. This is the Kshatriya category !
Then there is the fourth level of
people, whose goal is to cultivate their intellect to very high degree, but not
for any worldly gains or goals. Rather, for their living, they engage in
intellectual pursuits like teaching, paurohitya (पौरोहित्य),
while remaining in constant communion with all pervading divine presence (प्रभु
के सहारे). Other than these activities, rest of the time they strive to
keep their minds illuminated with the higher consciousness. That's the only
goal of the people in this fourth level. In Arya-Sanskriti (आर्य
संस्कृति), this is meant to be the level of Brahman (ब्राह्मण) category.
Whatever has been said about the
four categories above, in each one of these categories, many divisions are
possible on the basis of work and intellectual prowess demanded by them. In
fact such sub-divisions have been made indeed. On the basis of Sat (सत्)
and Asat (असत्), each category can be divided into atleast two
sub-divisions. These two sub-divisions can be further divided into many more
finer divisions. Although, humanity as a whole is a single category, but this
can be atleast be divided into the four developmental stages (विकास के चार
स्तर).
From the perspective of their inner
mental state and emotional makeup, people of Shudra category want to live a worryfree
(चिंता
रहित) life. Seeking long life of enjoyment with many children and grand
children, earning living (mostly wages) without taking any risks and thus
spending a life without worries. These are some of the characteristics of the
Shudra people. Such a life does not reflect and realize the growth potential of
a human life. Worry/uneasiness (चिंता) is the first step of
growth. Worry (चिंता) drives the deep thinking (चिंतन). This
deep thinking and contemplation alone proves the real human worth (मानव की सार्थकता). One who can't do this, they can't grow.
In Arya-Sanskriti (आर्य संस्कृति), that's what is
meant by 'Janmana Jayate Shudrah' (जन्मना जायते शूद्रः). As
all children are carefree and devoid of deep contemplative thinking, they are
called Shudra since birth. They become worthy of being called Dvija (द्विज),
only after going through the sanskars (संस्कार). For
sure, this sanskar is done precisely of mind (मन).
In vaishya category this worry (चिंता)
is visible at every step of the way. They can't spend a smooth, worry
free life (स्थिर निश्चिन्त जीवन). That's why they accomplish
growth in their life. By their special thought processes (चिंतन
प्रणाली), Vaishya
category is experienced (अनुभूत) in expansion of wealth, prosperity and
riches. People who engage in trade, business and related risky ventures are
counted in the Vaishya category. Manu has determined this category to be a
composite of Satyaanrit (सत्यानृत).
People in Kshatriya category are
seen to be even more so worried. They always keep their lives on their palms (प्राण
हथेली पर). When situation demands, they just couldn't care less about
their life, body, money or offspring. They are always ready to give it all up in the
defense of society and it's reputation (राष्ट्र/समाज की कीर्ति). That's
his honor. Even if this means loosing life, limbs or money, they are committed
to protect the honor. True Kshatriya protects his society from hurt, harm and
dishonor. Protects it from tyrants with full alertness. In words of
ancient symbolism, Khsatriya is, 'Gau-Brahman Pratipaalak' (गोब्राह्मण
प्रतिपालक). He is 'Satya-sandh' (सत्यसंध) ,
'Satyapakshee' (सत्यपक्षी), and 'Satya-sanrakshak' (सत्य-संरक्षक).
These are the central subjects in the Chitta (चित्त) of
a Kshatriya.
However, Brahman people have none
of these concerns like life (आयु), vigor/vitality (प्राण),
wealth (धन),
subjects (प्रजा) , fame (कीर्ति). Achieving Brahmvarchasva (ब्रह्मवर्चस्व) is their pre-eminent
goal. From universal view point (समष्टि दृष्टि), the
'dhyo tatva' (द्यो तत्व), which is permeating, pervading and
illuminating the whole existence in the form of Buddhi tatv (बुद्धि तत्व),
and the brilliance of Sat (सत का आलोक) which is existing
everywhere (सर्वव्याप्त), that is
the ultimate focus of attention of a Brahman. The Brahman's primary goal
is to experientially recognize this Truth and merge/dissolve his
individual Buddhi tatva (व्यष्टि बुद्धि तत्व) with the Universal. Achieveing
Dhee-Yoga (धी योग). This
is a state beyond thinking (चिंतन) and contemplation (मनन).
For sure a Brahman has to be an intellectual (चिंतनशील),
but, beyond that he also becomes enlightened (प्रकाश
संपन्न). Thus he is able to affect his entire surrounding by his
intense activities (गतिशीलता) driven by
Bramhteja (ब्रह्मतेज युक्त). People in his sphere of influence
feel this force and turn to move towards that direction. That's is how the
divine manifests (दिव्यता का प्रादुर्भाव) and affects (प्रभाव).
In Arya-Sanskriti (आर्य-संस्कृति),
this is called the growth of Brahmi-vritti (ब्राह्मी-वृत्ति सम्पादन). To
achieve the growth of Brahmi-vritti, Manu has prescribed and described the use
of svadhyaya (स्वाध्याय), vrat (व्रत), home-trayi vidyaa
(होम
त्रयी विद्या), ijyaa (इज्या), mahayagya (महायज्ञ).
Svadhyaya is sustained study of Veda, Shastra, volumes of Gyan-Vigyaan (ज्ञान-विज्ञान).
Vrata (व्रत) is achieving command over senses (इन्द्रिय-संयम)
by means like upavasa (उपवास). Daily agni-hotra (अग्निहोत्र), Veda-trayi behavior (वेदा-त्रयी
आचरण) of gyan-karma-upasana (ज्ञान, कर्म, उपासना), conduct of Darsh-paurnmaas yagya (दर्श-पौर्णमास
आदि यज्ञ), compliance of
Grihastha-dharma (गृहस्थ-धर्म) in bearing and raising children (संतति-प्रसव), Sarvhut-mahayagya (सर्वहुत महायज्ञ), Panch-mahayagya (पञ्च-महायज्ञ), and finally transforming the whole Yagya-inspired life (यज्ञ-पूर्ण
जीवन) into a life of yagya (यज्ञमय
जीवन), these are told to be
the means (साधन) for
achieving Brahmanatv (ब्राह्मणत्व). The final recourse of living a life of yagya (यज्ञमय जीवन), indicates the ultimate form of renunciation (त्याग की
पराकाष्ठा). Brahmans living
such a life only can fully
realize the pledge of Sanyaasi (सन्यासी की प्रतिज्ञा), where all ambitions of sons-wealth-fame (पुत्र-वित्त-यश
आकांक्षा) has to be totally renounced.
Shudra is
stagnant/passive (स्थिर). Vaishya
is action driven (गतिशील). Kshatriya
is even more highly action driven (अत्यधिक गतिशील). And Brahman who is ultimate in drive (परम-गतिशील), stays steady (स्थिर).
From
the perspective of human
development and growth also, above described four levels present a specific forward progression in life. Shudra, while earning routine living by being dependent
on other (पराश्रित), thus, he sometime gets offended/hurt and
then he strives to become independent and achieve financial security. This is the start of Shudra's
drive
towards vaishyahood/Vaishyatv (वैश्यत्व
की ओर प्रयाण). A vaishya produces and accumulates wealth,
but his worries for protecting and expanding his wealth, drives him to create resources and systems/processes that could guarantee a
relatively worryfree and safe surroundings.
And that's the transformation of vaishyahood/Vaishyatva (वैश्यत्व)
into Kshatriyahood/Kshatriyatv (क्षत्रियत्व).
Kshatriyatva or political
order (राजनीति) is
infested with lot of twist,
spin and distortions. In political order, 'Saam-Daam-Dand-Bhed'
(साम-दाम-दंड-भेद), become the
part of everyday conduct. Ordinarily, it is no easy job to earn fame. When one enters into politics, he first hand discovers this viciousness and
inner rot. Then he starts feeling restless from such human perversity and viciousness. And, now he starts seeking life of innocence and simplicity (सरलता
से संयुक्त जीवन). This intense aspiration is the movement towards
Brahmanhood / Brahmanatv (ब्राह्मणत्व की ओर प्रयाण). Brahman personifies simplicity and innocence. Miles away from deception and
conspiracies, Brahman is an icon of purity, openness and innocence (निष्कपट
भोलेपन की मूर्ति). Brahman belongs to all and all belong to him, then
with whom and why he will have deceptive
behavior. He is totally free (उन्मुक्त), open like a sky, blooming like a flower, showering happiness like moon rays, spreading light like a sun. Who in his
right senses would not love the Brahmanahood which is drenched in the rays of Supreme consciousness
(ब्रह्मरश्मियों में स्नात),
cleansed of all imperfections (विगतकल्मष), blissfully calm (शांत), and benign/kind (सौम्य).
Even if one doesn't actively
seek Brahmanatv, unknowingly everyone is sprinting in that direction. Mother nature is dragging us all
towards the Brahmanhood. Those, who are resisting this drive, either due to lethargy (प्रमादवश)
or due to their own stubbornness, such people are
unfortunate (अभागे). Otherwise,
it's desirable for everyone to move towards that 'dhyo' (द्यो), leaving behind their attachment of the dirt. Everybody aspires to move from Anna (अन्न) to Ananda (अनंद). Everybody loves to become Amrit (अमृत) leaving behind the Mrit (मृत).
In conclusion, it's worth repeating that, today, we should strive to achieve Brahmanhood,
but we need not completely ignore the
duties of Shudra, Vaishya and Kshatriya also. Shudra karma means the Seva of 'Viraat-Brahm' (विराट
ब्रह्म), the whole
manifest-universe. Vaishya karma means getting ride of our habit of greed and tame the tendency to accumulate wealth by
generous contributions towards society's wellbeing. Courage (साहस), valor (पराक्रम),
righteous anger/Manyu (मन्यु), and rage against injustice (अनीति के प्रति आक्रोश), these are the characteristics of a Kshatriya. These
three duties of Shudra,
Vaishya and Kshatriya, should be born simultaneously these days. This is the clarion call of Mahakal
(महाकाल की पुकार). This is
also His grand desire (महत इच्छा) and His aspiration (आकांक्षा) too.
*************
Primary Sources:
Complete works of Pt. Shriram
Sharma Acharya, Vol.34, Chapter.4
Rigveda
Yajurveda
Gita
